Do Athletes make too Much Money? Athletes vs. Gladiators

Recently many athletes have signed lucrative contracts with unimaginable amount of money. Examples of this are Justin Verlander who is a pitcher for the Detroit Tigers just signed a contract that will pay him $180 million dollars over the next 7 years. Doing the math, that puts him at about $25.7 million a year. In 2007 Alex Rodriguez signed a contract with the Yankees for 10 years and $252 million dollars; this is the richest contract ever for any athlete still today. Forbes in their most recent list of highest paid athletes put boxer Floyd Mayweather Jr. at number one reporting that he makes $85 million dollars a year. ( You may be wondering what this has to do with Rome, and that is a legitimate question.


In the Roman Empire, athletes participated in one of a few different events such as wrestling, chariot racing, or gladiatorial games. However, athletes in the Roman Empire did not hold the same social standing as athletes in our time. I’m going to focus on Gladiators which I am going to compare to athletes today. Gladiators were not the athletically gifted as they are today. They were often prisoners of war that would not accept Roman culture, slaves bought specifically for the purpose of fighting, or criminals that would serve their sentence by participating in the gladiatorial games. Occasionally free citizens would participate in the games but they were usually not high class citizens and would be social outcasts. The risk was high for the Gladiators; if they lost they most likely would not survive and would have their fate decided by the emperor or the judge of the games. If you were a loser and you were not executed you would be left with no social standing if you had any to begin with. You compare this to modern sports such as baseball where there are the largest contracts and if you lose a game in the regular season its not a big deal. Then for the Gladiators who won a couple of matches, their reward would be their freedom and a heightened social standing but they would not be given immense wealth like athletes now a days.


This is the basis for my question “Do athletes make too much money?” Back in the times of the Roman Empire if you lost a Gladiatorial match there was a possibility that you would survive if you fought well, but it was very unlikely that you would survive multiple losses. Last year the Chicago Cubs had a record of 61 wins and 101 losses which is a win percentage of 38%, so how does it make sense that Alfonso Soriano, an outfielder for the Cubs, made $19 million dollars last year. I’m not suggesting that the Cubs players should be executed because of all of their losses; I would suggest something such as giving them the same percentage of their salary as their win percentage for the season so that each game means more and that losing actually means they lose something. This still is not even nearly even the same as Gladiators because they would lose their life rather than some of their money. I would say that the only one that deserves all the money he makes is Floyd Mayweather Jr. because he is undefeated in his career in boxing and he participates in a sport that was around in the Roman Empire.


A final thing to consider is why modern athletes even get paid at all. I say this because in our times it is a privilege to play professional sports, so why should you get paid such a large amount for doing something you love so much? Shouldn’t we be paying our soldiers a lot more who are actually putting their lives on the line every day? These are just a few questions for you to ponder, and when you think about Gladiators in the Roman Empire and the compensation that they received, do athletes in our times make too much money?


How I Found my Sources: I knew the general figures for the contracts of the different athletes that I included in my blog, so I just googled them and confirmed them. But for the article I used for my information about Roman Gladiators I went to the alternative search engine and then I searched “Roman Gladiators” and picked the 6th site down. It was

which was an article in the Encyclopedia Romana written by the University of Chicago, and was a very objective article with no opinions and was just straight facts. So there was no author bias in the article.


– Skylar H.



6 thoughts on “Do Athletes make too Much Money? Athletes vs. Gladiators

  1. hopeadvancedlatin Post author

    I think athletes make too much money, but that’s just my biased opinion (as someone who isn’t a fan of sports in the slightest). Honestly, sports are all about entertainment. Some people are entertained, others aren’t. For those who are, maybe they’d agree with the salaries of professional athletes. If we were judging this by contribution to society, it seems unfair to me that artists who produce real art (not pop radio stars) can barely scrape together enough money to get by. Sports aren’t really contributing anything. Sure, they’re fun for some, but it seems like people make way too big of a deal about them. Unfortunately, capitalism as an economic system doesn’t choose what to support based on good for society… capitalism chooses whatever happens to be popular… and sports are incredibly popular.

    -Arbiter Bibendi

  2. hopeadvancedlatin Post author

    This is a very interesting comparison from the Roman ages to modern day. It seems as though both Romans and Americans both a have a very high regard for sports and entertainment. However, I feel as though they have a lot of similarities they are also different in a lot of ways. During the Roman empire there was a lot more sick and corrupted ways of entertainment. While America is not even close to clean, in the most popular sports there is a lot more sportsmanship and at worst there are accidental injuries. On the other hand, Romans did not care for a lot of the people they through into the arena and many of them were slaves or captives that had absolutely no rights. Therefore, they were not going to receive any sort of payment or reward as opposed to the superstars of today’s America.

  3. hopeadvancedlatin Post author

    Wow, Skylar. This is an awesome blog and topic. I can say I never actually thought about this, but it is so true. I love how you brought our current soldiers into this. Professional athletes shouldn’t be payed this much it’s ridiculous. They should be playing the game for the love of their profession not for the money. Soldiers do their profession with such little pay because they love this nation. I think as a nation we need to really think about this injustice. But, the hard question is, Where would we get the money to pay our soldiers as much as athletes or just more?

    -Sam Starks

  4. hopeadvancedlatin Post author

    Nice comparison, Skylar. I agree, athletes make a gross amount of money. I think it could be cool if you did another post on the gladiator owners and the coaches of these athletes that make so much bank. Given, the coaches don’t make as much money as the players, but it’s still quite a lot. And the coaches are serious celebrities (I grew up near MSU and went to school with the Izzo’s and Dantonio’s). Interesting stuff.

  5. hopeadvancedlatin Post author

    As much as i hate to go against the flow, it is really not outrageous what athletes are paid. Athletes, and for that matter everyone is paid based on their utility to their employer. im sure i could entertain a small audience by making stupid noises, but not a huge auditorium and definitely not the general public. Athletes are paid so much because of the money they bring in to their employer. They do something that other people can not do. this is why none of us can waltz up to the Bears and ask for a five million dollar quarterback contract. the people that employ these athletes earn much more than they pay them anyways, so is it really that unfair? when you really think about it, the average joe in the job market does not rake in nearly as much as Floyd Mayweather Jr., but that is because athletes produce a much more scarce and valuable resource. Just a thought from the economic side of things. -Nathanus Huber


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s